 |
|
|
| |
| Innovative
Approaches to HIV Outreach Along the US/Mexico Border |
| |
| Print the Complete Report (pdf 224KB). |
|
|
|
COMPLEX
HIV/AIDS ISSUES ALONG THE U.S./MEXICO BORDER
HIV/AIDS
is a significant problem along the 2,000-mile border between
the United States and Mexico, which stretches from California
to Texas. The HIV/AIDS epidemic in this region is made more
complex by many factors including Latino cultural norms regarding
sexuality, the rural nature of the border resulting in geographic
isolation and poverty, and lack of access to culturally sensitive,
high-quality health care. The challenge of reaching and providing
care to individuals infected and affected by HIV/AIDS is compounded
by these social, economic,
political, and cultural factors. For example, many individuals
cross back and forth over the border for seasonal work, making
it difficult to identify people who are at high risk for HIV/
AIDS. Because so many infected individuals along the border
do not know their HIV status, bringing people into testing
is a critical component of HIV/AIDS outreach.
|
|
|
| OVERVIEW |
|
The SPNS Border
Health Initiative has developed a wide range of approaches for conducting
outreach to migrant farm workers and other transborder populations
in the U.S./Mexico border region. The goal of the SPNS initiative
is to identify people who are HIVinfected and refer them to HIV
primary care in the early stages of the disease. The objectives
of the outreach efforts are to raise awareness about HIV, make HIV
testing more accessible, and bring people living with HIV into care.
The SPNS Border
Health Initiative uses both personal one-to-one contact and social
marketing to target the transient, largely Latino population in
the border region. The approaches reflect the unique nature of the
border area, where people are generally hard to reach and language
is a barrier for Spanish-speakers attempting to access healthcare
and HIV services.
One-to-one
outreach interventions include use of street outreach workers and
lay community health workers such as promotores, outreach to migrant
farm workers
in the workplace, outreach at truck stops and border crossings where
commuters wait in lines of traffic for periods of time, and outreach
to Latina women at events such as house parties.
The social
marketing campaigns use public media such as radio and TV to convey
messages to Hispanic communities, particularly rural and migrant
communities. SPNS border outreach interventions are sensitive to
the needs of people in the Latino culture, which values trust and
relationship-building.
The outreach
approaches developed by the SPNS projects can be used by other organizations
along the U.S./Mexico border to improve HIV/AIDS education and services
as well as to serve similar Hispanic populations throughout the
United States and abroad. The models can be further expanded to
reach underserved, hard-to-reach, at-risk individuals of any ethnicity
and in any geographic location. They can be adapted to other resource-poor
settings internationally where issues related to refugees, borders,
racial and ethnic minorities, and language barriers exist.
The purpose
of the Special Projects of National Significance (SPNS) program
is to advance knowledge and skills in the delivery of health and
social services to people with HIV infection who are financially
disadvantaged and medically underserved. The SPNS program, which
is administered by the Health Resources and Services
Administration (HRSA) HIV/AIDS Bureau (HAB), is funded by the Ryan
White Comprehensive AIDS Resources Emergency Act, also known as
the CARE Act.
when necessary.
TOP
|
| LAY
COMMUNITY HEALTH WORKERS |
|
Lay community
health workers are people from the targeted community who have been
trained to provide basic health education, amplifying the work of
professional health workers. The use of community health workers
can help to overcome the challenges facing Hispanic people along
the border, which include language differences, cultural barriers,
issues of immigration status, and frequent border
crossings. In addition, community health workers supplement the
inadequate number of health professionals in the region, particularly
ones who are culturally sensitive,
Spanish-speaking, and experts in HIV/AIDS.
Promotores,
community health workers who are volunteers or lay leaders,
are trained to provide health education and prevention services
to community members. They are often described as natural
helpers who are members of informal community support
systems. In the past many AIDS agencies have not used promotores
for HIV education and prevention because of concerns such as: the
need for confidentiality and for counseling before and after HIV
testing; cultural barriers related to asking about high risk behaviors
and sexual practices; and, the highly technical nature of information
regarding HIV treatment, including antiretroviral therapies. However,
the SPNS Border Health Initiative demonstrates that promotores can
be a valuable part of
the health care team who provide vital links with the targeted communities.
Key point:
Use trusted people from within the community to conduct the outreach,
in Spanish when necessary.
LAY COMMUNITY
HEALTH WORKERS IN ARIZONA
The Arizona
Border HIV/AIDS Care Project (ABHAC) uses promotores in several
of the counties it serves. The targeted populations are men who
have sex with men (MSM), injecting drug users (IDUs), sex partners
of migrant farm workers, and Latina women. Promotores from the collaborating
agencies Puentes de Amistad and Campesinos Sin Frontera work with
Health Department staff to conduct
the outreach.
LAY COMMUNITY
HEALTH WORKERS IN NEW MEXICO
The New Mexico
Border Health Initiative uses health outreach workers (HOWs) to
reach out to MSM, IDUs, and women. The HOWs are personally familiar
with the
populations they are engaging, which increases their effectiveness
as outreach workers. The HOW who targets injecting drug users is
an ex-drug-user and the HOWs who target men who have sex with men
are MSMs themselves they know the local places to go to reach
their audiences and how to discuss risk behaviors and risk reduction
with them.
To reach rural
communities, the initiative partners with local promotores projects
that lack the capacity to conduct HIV testing and counseling. These
include Mujeres Unidas en Acción contra el SIDA (MUACES,
or Women United in Action Against AIDS) and at the Ben Archer Health
Center (a maternal and child health center). HOWs organize house
parties and make door-to-door contacts, accept referrals
from promotores, and conduct weekly testing at MUACES.
The HOWs work
with individuals to identify their risk behaviors, teach them about
safer behaviors, develop risk reduction plans, and make referrals
when needed. They
conduct on-site oral HIV testing (OraSure). Outreach is conducted
both door-to-door and in groups called platicas, which are talks
in the home with up to eight participants.
Outreach in
the city also includes visits to the halfway house, homeless shelter,
and domestic violence shelter, and to areas where drug use and sex
work occur.
TOP
|
| OUTREACH
AT TRUCK STOPS AND BORDER CROSSINGS |
|
Truck drivers
are considered at high risk for HIV infection because they are away
from home for long periods of time, which often leads them to engage
in casual sex or to seek the services of sex workers. Truck stops
provide critical opportunities for identifying drivers as they cross
back and forth between the U.S. and Mexico. SPNS border projects
conduct outreach to truck drivers and other travelers who commute
across the border, taking advantage of their rest stops as well
as the long waiting times in lines of traffic at border crossings.
The outreach staff hand out HIV
prevention information and condoms, and in some projects, they conduct
in-field HIV counseling and testing.
Key point:
Reach people who are in transit by approaching them at truck
stops and border crossings. Go to locations where people are waiting
for long periods, which provides opportunities to talk at length.
OUTREACH
AT TRUCK STOPS AND BORDER CROSSINGS IN ARIZONA
The Arizona
Border HIV/AIDS Care Project (ABHAC) conducts outreach at truck
stops and at border crossings along the Mexico/Arizona border. On
the Arizona side in Nogales, outreach staff from Platicamos Salud
(Lets talk about health) have talked to truck drivers at the
truck stop and beside their trucks while they waited to cross the
border. Outreach staff supplies the truck stops with prevention
kits containing condoms and educational and testing information.
On the Sonora, Mexico side of the
border, staff from the collaborating agency Centro de Información
para la Salud (CISAL) walk the line of trucks waiting to cross the
border into the U.S., talking with
drivers and providing them with HIV information.
OUTREACH
AT TRUCK STOPS AND BORDER CROSSINGS IN CALIFORNIA
The Southern
California Border HIV/AIDS Project reaches out to transborder Latinos
at the San Ysidro/Tijuana border-crossing area. Outreach is conducted
around the
San Ysidro border entrance in bus stops, restaurants, and other
businesses where people are waiting for rides or going back and
forth to work. People frequent fast-food
restaurants and other businesses to eat, wait for rides, wait for
incoming family members, or conduct business among other travelers.
The waiting factor allows outreach workers more time to share information
and, when possible, to test individuals for HIV.
Outreach workers
also target the small buses that run along San Ysidro Boulevard
from the border, displaying brochures and talking with commuters.
Outreach is
productive here because the small buses have a 20- to 30- minute
wait time. The bus drivers, who have become familiar with the outreach
workers, refer people to the
workers and even allow time for HIV tests.
Although people
who are commuting are in transit, they come through at the same
time every day, making followup possible. Staff return to a given
location for at least 2
weeks in a row, enabling them to find people who were tested and
give them their test results.
TOP
|
| OUTREACH
TO MIGRANT FARM WORKERS |
|
Several SPNS
Border Initiative projects conduct outreach to migrant farm workers,
which involves careful planning: obtaining cooperation of the farm
foremen, adapting to
the schedules of the workers long days, and traveling to many
different sites to meet with them. Staff conduct outreach at campsites,
nurseries, corner stops, transit
stations and apartment complexes. They work in the early morning
and also during the lunch hour, providing large and small group
presentations as well as one-to-one testing, support, and referrals.
Key point:
Go to transit and meeting locations at the times when workers gather
to go to and from the fields.
OUTREACH
TO MIGRANT FARM WORKERS IN ARIZONA
The Arizona
Border HIV/AIDS Care Project (ABHAC) conducts outreach to migrant
farm workers during the harvest season (October through February).
Outreach staff and promotores talk with the workers beginning at
4 a.m. as they gather at corners, gas stations, or in the park waiting
to be picked up by the buses that transport them
to the fields. Contact is also made during the workers lunch
breaks if the mayordomo (foreman) gives permission, and outreach
staff have encountered little resistance from the farm foremen.
Finally, staff approach workers at the end of the workday when they
are returned to the pick-up locations. Outreach staff give them
information packets including HIV/AIDS and STD information, two
condoms, and a card with HIV testing
site information.
OUTREACH
TO MIGRANT FARM WORKERS IN CALIFORNIA
The Southern
California Border HIV/AIDS Project targets migrant workers in many
areas where they congregate at bus stops, houses, packing
sheds, fields, unemployment offices, markets, and directly along
the U.S./Mexico border. Materials for outreach include Spanish-language
brochures and novelitas on HIV. For the first contact, promotores
go alone. Later, the promotores return with the person conducting
HIV testing, who provides oral testing on-location and then gives
results during a later
visit. HIV testing is also conducted at recovery homes, construction
sites, and adult education centers.
The staff arrange
their schedules around the most convenient times for the farm workers,
beginning their day at the bus stops at 3 am, when farm workers
are waiting for the bus to arrive. Promotores also obtain permission
from packing shed supervisors to talk to the employees about HIV
during their 15-minute breaks. The promotores themselves have worked
in the fields and packing sheds before, and therefore they relate
well to the target population.
The sex workers
based near the migrant camps are women who are at especially high
risk for HIV. They are contacted through a trusted promotora who
has worked in community health for decades. She has arrangements
with the owners of brothels to provide condoms and HIV counseling
and testing to the sex workers.
TOP
|
| HOUSE
PARTIES FOR LATINA WOMEN |
|
Latina women
living in border areas are at risk for HIV infection because their
husbands may engage in high risk behaviors while working away from
home. For instance, many migrant farm workers leave home for long
periods of time during crop-picking season while their wives stay
at home. House parties provide culturally-appropriate, safe surroundings
for reaching out to Latinas residing along the border. The party
hostesses are often identified by promotoras, who are responsible
for health education on many topics in the community. The parties
are presented as an opportunity to participate in their communitys
wellness and are not linked to the topic of HIV. The parties usually
include 5-10 women who are friends invited by the hostess. Difficult
topics such as sex and risk behaviors can be discussed, and education
and HIV testing can occur in this confidential environment. They
are staffed informally by a person from the Health Department and
a promotora, who are responsible for providing prevention information
as well as for conducting HIV counseling and testing.
Key point:
Provide a confidential setting in which a trusted group of friends
can discuss sensitive issues with a health care provider.
HOUSE PARTIES
FOR LATINA WOMEN IN ARIZONA
The Arizona
Border HIV/AIDS Care Project (ABHAC) uses house parties to educate
Latina women about HIV testing. An increase in the number of women
with HIV infection, most of whom had no risk factors other than
their husbands having sex outside the marriage, prompted an aggressive
outreach to increase HIV testing among Latinas.
House parties
provide an opportunity for the Yuma County Health Department to
educate women on multiple topics including overall health, diabetes,
STDs, and HIV
prevention and testing. The participants have been receptive to
talking about sensitive issues regarding sex and infidelity because
they are with friends and knowledgeable, caring health professionals.
Oral HIV testing
is conducted, and women retrieve their test results at the Health
Department a few days after the party, where results are given in
person by the Health
Department staff. The promotora only provides support if the woman
chooses to disclose the result to her.
TOP
|
| SOCIAL
MARKETING TO BORDER COMMUNITIES |
|
SPNS Border
Health Initiative projects have launched extensive social marketing
campaigns to educate Latino communities along the border about the
risk of HIV/AIDS and to encourage people to get tested for HIV and,
if needed, to enter into HIV care services. Social marketing campaigns
utilize Spanish language media, including radio, TV, and printed
materials, to convey culturally appropriate messages to large numbers
of people in the targeted communities. The goal of these campaigns
is not only to provide information to large numbers of people but
to change perceptions about HIV in the community.
Key point:
Convey bold HIV messages in public media campaigns to normalize
the idea that HIV is a community problem and to identify testing
and clinical resources for people.
SOCIAL MARKETING
TO BORDER COMMUNITIES IN CALIFORNIA
The Southern
California Border HIV/AIDS Project conducted the Tu No Me Conoces
(You Dont Know Me) campaign targeting Latinas, MSMs, and farm
workers. The campaign ran a radio commercial on four Spanish language
radio stations popular with Latinos. The campaign wording was bold
and direct to catch Latinos attentioneven though it
was not in line with most Latino efforts to keep illnesses like
HIV/AIDS private and attuned to cultural norms. The shock
value of the campaign was critical to normalizing the presence
of HIV in the Latino community and encouraging Latinos to recognize
HIV as a community problem. The ads provided a 1-800 phone number
and a Web site with counseling/testing site locations.
Although two
ads were originally developed, focus groups consisting of Latinas,
MSMs, and farm workers selected one commercial targeting a mix of
these populations.
Followup calls
demonstrated that the commercial was broad enough to reach all of
the target groups. Project staff believe that the campaign has brought
attention to
HIV and has identified service locations for potential clients.
SOCIAL MARKETING
TO BORDER COMMUNITIES IN TEXAS
Proyecto Juntos
of the Valley AIDS Council in Harlingen, Texas implemented a social
marketing campaign targeting Latina women in the lower Rio Grande
Valley.
The aim was
to educate Latinas who speak limited English about possible risks
and signs of HIV disease and to motivate them to seek HIV counseling
and testing. The
campaign was conducted over a 6-month period and included spots
on Spanish language TV and radio. The spots were aired in the morning
as well as in the afternoon during programming popular with Latina
women such as telenovelas, or Mexican soap operas. Well-known
local media personalities volunteered their time for the TV spots.
During the
media campaign, Spanish/English posters and brochures were distributed
to places where Latinas congregate, including washaterias
and beauty shops.
The ads provided a phone number to call, where social marketing
staff gave callers basic HIV information, screened them for HIV
risks, and referred them to counseling and testing sites when appropriate.
The largest source of calls received was in response to the ads
on Spanish TV. The nature of the responses indicated that
there is much need among Latina women for continued education about
HIV and risk.
Typical comments included:
- Nosotros
como hispanas necesitamos perder el miedo y la verguenza y debemos
hacernos la prueba para saber si tenemos VIH o SIDA. (We
Hispanics need to lose our fear and shame and get tested so that
we know whether we have HIV or AIDS.)
- Es mejor
prevenir que tener que lamentar. (Its better
to prevent than have to be sorry.)
- Estoy muy
agradecida que ustedes estan haciendo este proyecto para que nosotras
nos podamos hacer la prueba gratis. (I am so very
grateful that you
are doing this project so that we can take the test free of cost.)
TOP
|
| LESSONS
LEARNED |
|
The outreach
approaches developed by the SPNS Border Health Initiative include
innovative ways to make personal, one-to-one contact in Spanish
as well as culturally specific social marketing campaigns in Spanish
language media. Using these approaches, staff and community health
outreach workers such as promotores have conducted successful outreach
in places where people work (eg, nurseries, farms, and truckstops
along the highway), where they commute (eg, border crossings), and
where they live (eg, house parties). Social marketing campaigns
involve blanketing the community with messages that work to reverse
the cultural norm that topics related to sexuality, including HIV,
are not discussed in public.
TOP
|
|